First let me just say that I feel quite accomplished; I consider actually finishing Paul Virilio‘s Open Sky to be a great feat, especially since all of the physics he incorporates was just as incomprehensible to me as Chinese. But…on to my final thoughts.
At the conclusion of Open Sky, we are left with a paradox: that, at least in Virilio’s view, virtuality has diminished the vastness of the world while simultaneously forging a greater distance between humans. These two oppositional forces manifest/will manifest themselves in a couple of different ways:
- Eye lust – the obsession of researchers with optics and controlling, enhancing, and incorporating technological prostheses into our organs of vision demonstrates how sight is no longer a limiting factor in perception. In other words, technology enables us to see things far beyond our range of vision, thus eliminating the distance from point A to point B and making the world considerably smaller.
- Sexual diversion – conversely to “eye lust,” which promotes the shrinkage of distance, cybersex, by its very nature, promotes the distancing of human beings. Indeed, it depends entirely upon geographically isolated partners. Virilio attributes the human attraction to such an impersonal sex to this very distancing; the sex partner doesn’t share one’s tangible space and so can’t rearrange one’s home or be in the way when one is trying to get ready for work in the morning. Although I still believe that mankind will NEVER ultimately favor cybersex to actual sexual intercourse, I think Virilio’s theory explains why many people, especially those in committed relationships, turn to pornography and webcam sex in moments of lust; they feel they can “get off” without having to deal with the rest of the ups-and-downs that come with a real life relationship. To many, again especially to many who are in committed relationships, a web session is impersonal, so it’s “not the same” as cheating. This sort of attitude certainly DOES promote a divide in society.
All in all, I think Virilio is right to call into question the motives behind our rush to be the most wired people in history. But I don’t see our fundamental humanity – our desires, our motivations, and our actions – as being in the sort of cataclysmic danger Virilio supposes them to be in. We will still travel, we will still work, we will still get off of our sofas, and, yes, we will still have sex until our race is nonexistent. Yes, technology has influenced HOW we do all of those things, but not in entirely negative ways. It’s important to balance the positive and negative, something I don’t think Virilio does very well.
Discussion
- How do you interpret Virilio’s comparison (in the final chapter) of our supposed fate to Buzz Aldrin’s commission to a psychiatric ward?
- Virilio ultimately believes that real time is superseding real space? Do you agree? Is this a complete supersession? Is this a necessarily bad thing?







